MEDIA INTERPRETATION - HOLSWORTHY AIRPORT PROPOSAL


"HOLSWORTHY REPORTS COSTLY"

SMH, FRIDAY, JUNE 20, 1997

"The Department of Defence has spent $300,000 on consultancy reports as part of a growing campaign against use of the Holsworthy Military Reserve, near Liverpool, for Sydney's second airport.

A leaked internal departmental brief states that use of Holsworthy would greatly reduce the Army's training capacity and adversely affect its "operational readiness" in relation to its Sydney-based units."

The article further quotes the Federal Opposition defence spokesman, Mr Arch Bevis, as saying that "such large expenditures on impact assessments showed that Holsworthy was firming as the most likely site for the new airport"


MAYOR OF WOLLONGONG REJECTS SSRAHA AIRPORT PROTEST

SOURCE: "The Advertiser" June 4, 1997. Lorraine Pitt.

"An unprecedented call for international tourists to boycott Australia, pressurising the Federal Government to reject Holsworthy as a second airport site, has received the thumbs down from Wollongong Lord Mayor David Campbell. Councillor Campbell said the demand, issued by the action group Sutherland Shire Residents Against Holsworthy Airport, was not in the interests of the anti-Holsworthy movement and would be "cutting off their noses to spite their faces" Action group chairman Phil Smith has said the health of local residents and the lives of two of Sydney's remaining koala colonies were at stake and so drastic action was called for".

Mayor Campbell reinforces his anti-Holsworthy position however, and Cr Kerrie Christian, Wollongong City Council's representative on CRASH (Councils and Residents Against the Selection of Holsworthy), although understanding of SSRAHA's concerns, "would not go that far". "We have to keep putting pressure on the Government but it's not going to help by putting jobs at risk in the hotels and airports and other ancillary services".


May 7, 1997. Sydney Morning Herald (Murray Hogarth): "EPA gives both airport sites the thumbs down".

The Sydney Morning Herald's environment writer reports that the EPA is not keen on either second airport sites, Badgerys Creek or Holsworthy. The EPA is particularly concerned about the environmental impacts on the Badgerys Creek site, but acknowledges that more information is known about this site due to investigations over a period of 17 years since Badgerys was established as the site of Sydney's second airport. "Both of the sites proposed for Sydney's second airport will increase the petrochemical smog crisis, disrupt sleep and pollute vital water supplies, according to a leaked report from the State's environmental watchdog. Emissions from both sites will impact on residential areas - the delicacy of air quality in the south-west sub-region means that every avenue to control emission levels must be explored."

MY COMMENT: It reinforces what we have all been saying. The Holsworthy proposal is flawed on a number of fronts and the current preliminary EIS is a farce. Potential pollution and noise impact issues are already well understood by the general community. Citizens intuitively know that pollution will not only be confined to designated flight paths but will will affect the whole of the Sydney basin. Pollution does not respect boundaries. Most of the population in the region will not settle for anything less than the removal of Holsworthy proposal from the Federal Government's agenda.

For full text, or to get backcopies contact the S.M.H. by clicking on this link:


April 30, 1997. Source: ABC Television News footage: Transport Minister's driver decks an Anti-Holsworthy protestor in Sydney (Ingelburn) - my interpretation:

Angry anti-Holsworthy citizens (about 200 in number), driven to protest by the Federal Government's silence and blatant lack of consultation with the community over the Holsworthy issue, presented themselves at a facility opening today by Mr Sharp, the Minister of Transport. Symbolic of the Government's attitude towards citizens affected by Sydney's second airport proposal, a 71 year old protestor was virtually "run down" by the Minister's driver. He received lacerations and bruising.

A police enquiry is underway and the driver may be charged.

My Comment: What will the future bring if this Government powers on and selects Holsworthy as the new airport site? Mass civil disobedience that has not been seen for many a year in Australia.


April 28, 1997. Article in Illawarra Mercury (page 3) entitled "Holsworthy favoured for airport: ALP -McLachlan under fire"

"Defence Minister Ian McLachlan's comments on television were the clearest indication yet that Holsworthy was now the favored second airport site, Opposition defence spokesman Arch Bevis said yesterday. "His statement that he had an "open mind" about Holsworthy in spite of the fact that it is one the very few live firing ranges in south-east Australia and location of some $150 million in new defence buildings is akin to hoisting the white flag," Mr Bevis said. "If there is anyone in Cabinet who should have a clear and strong opinion about Holsworthy it should be the Defence Minister"

It appears from the article that the Minister has "an open mind on the matter" and "could not make any judgements until such time as that EIS is done." Mr McLachlan further added that "the EIS might well rule out Holsworthy - if it doesn't then there will be some very detailed considerations" he said.

For full text, or to get backcopies contact the Illawarra Mercury by clicking on this link:


April 26, 1997. Article in Sydney Morning Herald by Murray Hogarth entitled "Battle against second airport takes to the trees" Page 14.

This article in the Sydney Morning Herald, highlights the potential plight of Koala colonies at the Holsworthy site should construction proceed.

"Threatened Koalas in two small colonies are to be promoted as wildlife icons in an international campaign against Holsworthy army base becoming the site of Sydney's massive 24 hour airport. Environmentalists fear that the Federal Government has secretly discarded Badgerys Creek in favor of the sprawling wilds of Holsworthy, in Sydney's south, with northern or southern airport alternatives.

Researchers who are tracking Koalas in the area say both Holsworthy options are a "great threat" to the animals, which can be highly mobile, and would directly kill many and dangerously isolate others.

"Its quite ironic" said Mr Steven Ward from the University of Western Sydney's Macarthur campus. "They might put an airport in supposedly for a lot of tourists to come in, and wipe out a lot of Koalas which is the main reason for tourists to come".

From today, the Councils and Residents Against Selection of Holsworthy (CRASH) group is starting to promote the potential plight of the Koalas to major overseas media outlets, and is planning to give them star billing on the Internet."

The article further describes the significance of the colonies in the area as the "most important in the Sydney basin." Koala numbers in the area number about 60 per colony but the number across Holsworthy is a "great unknown." The fear is that the Government will not rigorously apply adequate environmental assessment standards with the regards to the colonies. Researchers also fear that the construction of infrastructure to support the airport, such as roads and rail access, would have a dramatic impact on the Koalas.


April 20, 1997. Sun Herald - Alex Mitchell - Entitled "Holsworthy certain site of airport"
Alex Mitchell writes that the the military reserve at Holsworthy, south of Sydney on the edge of the Royal National Park, will be the site of Sydney's new international airport.  Its not official yet but it will be in a few months. His seven signs pointing towards this decision:

  • The Howard Government decided last week to sell the Bringelly RAAF receiving station, only a couple of kilometers from the Badgerys Creek airport site.
  • In December, the government sold a parcel of Commonwealth land adjacent to Badgerys Creek  - the 344ha CSIRO site.
  • On April 8, Tourism Council Australia announced that they endorsed Holsworthy as the preferred option.
  • Sydney's Inner Metro Regional Organization of Councils called for the closure of Kingsford Smith Airport by 2015.
  • Two interim reports on runway and transport options by Rust PPK tipped the balance away from Badgerys.
  • In the next phase - investigating noise pollution - earlier levels relating to Badgerys Creek will be revised upwards and Holsworthy , because of its size and location , will get the green light.
  • Two weeks ago Olympics Minister abandoned the plan to hold shooting at Holsworthy, the nominated site during the Sydney's games bid, and named Cecil Park as the new venue.

April 20, 1997,  Stanwell Park:  3000 angry Anti-Holsworthy protestors crammed into Stanwell Park today, to protest the airport proposal.  Robert Tickner, amongst others, did not have to stimulate the crowds too much - they were already angry against the Federal Government's undemocratic proposal.  The crowd formed  a giant  "NO"  to circling planes, press helicopters, and hang gliders.  Organization on the day was nothing short of excellent.  Channels 9, 7, and ABC are carrying news traffic on this event tonight.

April 8, 1997:  Tourism Council of Australia endorses Holsworthy as the preferred option for a second airport for Sydney.  "At a meeting of the national peak body, Tourism Council Australia's (TCA) policy think-tank in Brisbane, Holsworthy was supported because of its access to public transport, proximity to the Sydney CBD, commercial feasibility for aiport users, cost effectiveness, provision of associated infrastructure and expansion space for further growth." 


OTHER RECENT NEWS ITEMS

RELEASE OF DRAFT EIS DELAYED UNTIL JUNE 1997
DEPT MINERAL RESOURCES OPPOSES HOLSWORTHY - VAST COAL DEPOSITS
PROPOSED FLIGHT PATHS LEAKED
NOISE IMPACT EXTENDS TO WOLLONGONG
HELENSBURGH NO.1 COMPLAINTS
HOLSWORTHY UNSAFE WHILE LUCAS HEIGHTS REACTOR IN OPERATION


THE HOLSWORTHY AIRPORT ISSUE

JULY 27, 1997. 20,000 PROTEST HOLSWORTHY MAIN SITE H.A.D. I.T. EXCLUSIVE NEWSFLASH H.A.D. I.T. ALERTS RECENT NEWS
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES NOISE & POLLUTION HOW TAINTED? ACTION CHECKLIST PROTEST MEETINGS COMMUNITY DIVIDED
THE SHAME FILE PETER'S VIEWS THE VIEWS OF OTHERS CHECKING RUMOURS CONFERENCING OTHER WEB SITES